Which change deserves the next PHB experiment?
A coupled process model moved full-cycle productivity ahead of dilution as the strongest cost lever in this PHB screening study. The result gives a team a sharper experiment to run, not a plant cost forecast.
The decision
For a PHB process, should development effort go toward a faster production cycle, lower broth dilution, or better polymer recovery? Each can look attractive in isolation. But dilution also changes biomass formation, PHB content, oxygen demand, pumping, and separation work. A comparison that leaves those effects apart can point to the wrong next experiment.
Ayomic compared the options at the same output target: 1.5 million kilograms of recovered PHB per year at 99.9% mass purity. The screening model used a generic European 2024 cost setting and considered three recovery routes.
What changed the answer
Under the central alkali recovery assumptions, doubling full-cycle productivity reduced modeled unit cost more than improving recovery. Reducing dilution alone increased it once the linked biological and separation penalties were included.
| Modeled option | Unit cost | Annual modeled cost |
|---|---|---|
| Baseline | €9.0896/kg | €13,634,340 |
| 2× full-cycle productivity | €6.9299/kg | €10,394,799 |
| Less dilution | €9.7552/kg | €14,632,871 |
| Better recovery | €8.9775/kg | €13,466,202 |
Across 512 paired model-input draws, productivity ranked first in 96.7–98.6% of draws across the three recovery routes. That measures robustness within the chosen assumptions. It is not a probability that productivity will win at a real site.
How the comparison was made
The study linked biological yield and PHB content to downstream recovery, utilities, and cost accounting, then compared the same process changes across three recovery routes. An independent recalculation checked the equations and 31 selected results; the central mass and water balances closed in those checks.
The outcome is a practical test order: measure whether higher full-cycle productivity survives the real oxygen, cooling, and recovery demands of the process. A prior comparison that treated dilution separately favored dilution; the coupled analysis supersedes that ranking.
What still needs proof
- Measure the biological penalty from concentration and dilution changes at the intended process scale.
- Confirm aeration, cooling, pumping, and route-specific recovery at matched PHB purity.
- Replace generic costs with site tariffs, equipment estimates, and vendor quotes before investment decisions.
This is a custom coupled screening and accounting model, not a validated plant design or a validated full-plant BioSTEAM techno-economic analysis. No physical cost reduction has been demonstrated.
Sources
Study snapshot: 13 October 2026. Public PHB/PHA process literature served as comparator context: Water Research (2012) and Bioresource Technology (2015). These papers did not calibrate the scenario costs shown here.